Skip to content


Is It Shiloh or Is It Knox?

italy1

New photos of the Jolie-Pitt family in Venice just surfaced and there is a lot of debate going on. Take a look at the photo above. Some, like Perez, are saying that it is Knox Jolie-Pitt. But others are saying that even though the hair is a bit darker, it’s Shiloh.

I’m actually 99% sure that Perez is wrong and that it’s Shiloh. Shiloh has had her tooth out for awhile now and this child is larger than the last photos we’ve had of Knox.

Update: even MSNBC is now saying that it is Knox!

What do you think? Is it Shiloh or is it Knox?

(also included are a few cute photos of Angelina and Brad with Zahara – how adorable is Princess Zee?)

Posted in Angelina Jolie, Brad Pitt, Knox Jolie-Pitt, Shiloh Jolie-Pitt, Zahara Jolie-Pitt.

Tagged with , , , , .


21 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Kara says

    This dude is much larger than Knox, seen being carried by Brad on the 16th. It also doesn’t look like Shiloh, who has beautiful blond hair and much fuller lips. Check out the pics on http://jjb.yuku.com/topic/590125/t/Brad-Angelina-Children-MEGA-POST-Part-10.html?page=508 and compare. Perhaps this is a cousin, friend, or a new adoption?

  2. finola says

    its shiloh not knox its to tall to be knox.

    that what i think.

  3. cadf says

    This is Shiloh. Look at the shoes. They are the same shoes in the one below where the kids are having ice cream. The one of Angelina by herself.

  4. cadf says

    Sorry the one under Angelina by herself.

  5. stratoula says

    I think this is little Shiloh!Yes this child is too big to be Knox but if you check out another pic on jjb you will see that this child is missing a tooth.And so is Shi!Plus I think this is the jacket that Shi wore when they were out for an ice cream 2 days ago,and I think she wears the same shirt too.You can see the pic I’m talking about here: http://thejjb.com/topic/585114?page=1160
    Anyway,this child is simply adorable just like Princess Zee!!!I think Zee is getting cuter and cuter every day!!!It looks like they are going to have a very fun and creative day(just see what Angie is holding) with their gorgeous parents!!!Thanks Randi!!!

  6. Mary Ann says

    The child Brad is holding looks way to tall to be Knox, but I think this child has boys clothes on. Boy, I can’t tell. On the smaller middle picture of Brad handing off a child, I believe that is Knox.

  7. isacutie says

    Agree that the child looks too big to be Knox, and the shoes do seem to match what Shiloh was wearing in the earlier pictures. Since Shiloh’s been known to like boyish clothes, I think it’s her just that perhaps at the moment the picture was taken she looks a more like Knox. :-) Anyways, thanks for the pics.

  8. isacutie says

    Oops, comment under mod. Wonder why. But first things first, thanks for these new pics.

  9. czechjoyce says

    I agree this is definitely Shiloh..same shoes and dressed the way Shi likes to dress…

  10. finola says

    omg i know isaid it was shiloh, but i dont know now who it is,if it shiloh she has change
    so much from the side it looking like shiloh in one picture

  11. GeGe says

    I have to say the first time I saw the pics I knew it was Shiloh……I saw the baby pics and knew this big kid couldn’t be Knox…..even the tooth missing confirmed it for me.

  12. Mary says

    Unless little Knox has grown significantly in two days, that is Shiloh. Just look at the photos of Brad holding Knox and where his legs are and compare to where this child’s legs are.

  13. Kati says

    At first I really thought it is Knox but after taking another closer look at this pic it turns out to be Shiloh after all. I got too excited too soon. I noticed another thing that reveals it must be Shi and it´s the fact that this child seems to be too tall for being a 19-month-old. So it has to be Shi. But my God! At which point has her hair turned brown? Or has Angie let her hair be dyed? The clothes can easily be explained. Shi loves to wear boys´ clothes since she obviously is going through a tomboy phase. And one other thing tells that it must be Shi after all. Zee and Shi always go out together. I´ve hardly ever seen a pic in which these two sisters aren´t together. Sometimes they have one of their big bros in tow but otherwise they seem to an unbreakable duo. So my final judgement is:this is Shi!

  14. Kati says

    stratoula – I have to agree with you. I went to jjb and looked at those pics and saw something. Shi truly is wearing the same shirt she was wearing on Tuesday (Feb 16) when the family went for the ice-cream. And she also wearing the same shoes. Now I don´t have any more doubts about who this child is. It´s beautiful Miss Shiloh! And besides I remember seeing many pics in which she is wearing those same gray pants. She has changed so much lately but only for the better. That brown hair color suits her very well. Doesn´t if it´s dyed or natural change of color. My guess is that it has changed naturally during the last few months. We haven´t seen her without a hat for months now so it may very well be that the change has happened naturally. Brown or blond this girl is still a stunner! Watch out boys! Shi is gonna break your hearts when she grows up! LOL!

  15. Kati says

    I just can´t get enough of watching that first pic under the caption. It tells that it definitely is Shiloh. She´s had that same facial expression many times and that gave her away. And the way she´s sucking her thumb is another sign that speaks on Shi´s behalf. That shorter hairstyle with bangs really suits her well. Maybe she got fed up with that long hair and told her parents that she wants to have her hair cut shorter. She still is a very beautiful little girl. Hard to imagine that she´ll soon be 4 years old! And Zee looks absolutely adorable too! Her smile is just beautiful! For once she´s not letting the paps ruin all the fun she, her parents and little sis are about to have. She is a beauty in the making! And probably also a future model or actress in the making too!

  16. Elizabeth says

    That child is way too big to be Shiloh. From the picture of Brad carrying Knox from just a few days ago, it’s an obvious size difference. I’d say they let her dye her hair. Even with hats on you’ve still been able to see wisps of her light blond hair sticking out. There’s a post just last month on Jan. 18th that shows pictures of Shiloh and you can see she definitely has light blond hair. Can’t imagine why anyone would dye her hair at 3 1/2 years old, but either way, she’s a little cutie!

  17. Mary Ann says

    I don’t think Angie would die Shiloh’s hair. In the winter hair turns darker. My 10 year old grandaughter has blond hair in the summer and brown hair right now in the winter. Another thought is the colors that kids spray in their hair for party’s or Halloween. But it doesn’t look that either. I just think her is darker because it is winter.

  18. Kati says

    Elizabeth – that child isn´t too big to be Shiloh. She has grown a lot lately and if you take a closer look at those pics that were taken earlier this week when the JPs were going for the ice-cream you can see that Zee and Shi are almost as tall. And Zee is only a year older than Shi. Angie has told many times that her own mum dyes her hair whwn she was a child. Until then she was blond.

  19. Elizabeth says

    Ooops. I meant to type that child is way too big to be KNOX. My mistake. Ha ha ha. :)

  20. tracy says

    Totally Shiloh!

  21. SARA says

    IT’S SHILOH. BEAUTIFUL CHILD. WATCH OUT WORLD WHEN SHE GROW’S UP.